No he did not beat me in a fair fight. LoL! He beat me, but it was certainly not a fair fight. And it was dishonorable. Just think about it: you have a fully leveled fighter and you want to use him for his intended purpose. So you find a gang and get into TC. Your opponents are also there to TC, so it's honorable. Or you solo in New Reno against other fighters. Once again your enemies are brutal, but you're there to PvP so it's honorable. Or you go to Hinkley where fighters gather to fight honorably.
But if you're a reckless brutal meanihead, you hunt a brand new guy who has no weapon or any weapon skill yet. He's working hard to craft stuff that you might be able to buy. He could use your advice about the game and some help getting started. He finally got a hammer and he's so excited to find the mine! He has no expectation of a fight with you since he's clearly minding his own business mining. And...you murder him. You shoot him in the back with a plasma rifle and he melts into goo. No warning. No challenge. No xp earned. You were just bored and you have no sense of fairness or honor. You simply don't care if new players quit and you're too stupid to make the connection between unchecked tyranny, people quitting, and donation money going with them. You don't connect the dots because, in my example, you're a heartless, mindless, immature thug who just cannot cut it in a real PvP fight. Your victims wonder if there are any fair fights in the game because that one certainly wasn't one.
But BenK, i'm glad you're not like that. I bet you're one of the nicer guys here. I think i can tell. But you need to not react first - just think and wait to reply. Connect those dots above. Because you're arguing on the wrong side!
PS: nothing wrong with mining HQ, and nothing wrong with a level 3 miner, and it would be weird to mine with a team of mercs. More weird ideas from BenK, one of the nicest guys here.