I'm going to be as honest about this as I possibly can, assigning stats as I see fit and offering explanations for each.
ST: 5
I don't work out regularly and I've never been a natural athlete, but I spent four years in a tough military high school and six in the Air Force, so I'm about average strength.
PE: 7
I was born with poor eyesight, so normally I'd have a 3 here, but corrective surgery gave me 20/20 vision, so it increases to 6. I also have good hearing and keen general awareness, so a further +1. I own firearms and regularly shoot them, and I know I'm quite a fair shot, so overall I think 7 is fair with the surgery.
EN: 5
Again, military school and the military made me tough enough for a 6. Recently however, I'd say it's dropped to 4 (poor running endurance for example). But, I have a very strong constitution and almost never get sick (and have no allergies), so an additional +1 is in order, I think.
CH: 6
I have a fairly powerful personality, am a good public speaker, and am very well-spoken in general. Normally I'd rate this as high as an 8. However, I'm not really a natural leader or a people person, so in all fairness, it's 6 at the most.
IN: 7
I'd like to think I'm an 8 in this department, and perhaps I am, but if anything that just means I should take -1 to offset my own bias. I have no doubt I'm comfortably above average in the intellect department, though. This is always the trickiest one for us all to rate — it's one thing to be skinny or sickly, but everyone hates being stupid or even just average.
AG: 5
I live a fairly sedentary life, I've never been very flexible and I've gained a spot of weight recently, so this should be as low as 4. However, I have good reflexes and pretty decent manual dexterity, so 5 it is.
LK: 3
I'm not particularly unlucky, but I'm never LUCKY, either, you know? Plus, good things don't ever simply happen to me in life. I have to make them happen. So, this is a definite 3.
Tags: Science (I love science), Speech (good speaker, strong command of English), Sneak, maybe? (believe it or not, I got lots of practice with this when young)
Traits: Will have to think about it.
* * * * * * * * * * * *
So overall, I'm about a 6 — taking all aspects into account, that's slightly above average. I think that's reasonable, and that many middle-class American young people my age would fall into the same category, be they good athletes, natural leaders, of above-average intelligence, lucky bastards, or whatever.