well,the ideea in Fallout is to "survive the post-apocaliptic war"so you must survive
and i can't tell someone surviving whitout water or food
i sugest this hunger and thirst needs shoud depend on Endurance
Plus,2 noncombat profesions in plus(farmers,chefs/cokers)will be a nice addition,+some farmer houses,or even upgraded tents, i will add a topic like this in the forum
nice ideea, i thing,will bring a new chalange in the game,but i thing the best penaltys whoud be str and skill penaltys,or even some dmg rezistance reduced
and this penaltys and needs shoud not be "reseted" by death,like the drug adictions,you die an a part of them will be cured,but not 100%
and i do not wanna troll, but i think those that hates the ideea are just some "youngsters whit a blood thirst" that can't do anything constructive, but to shoot, distroy, suicide bombing, and PK/anti-PK power bilding,(i am not refering to all that hate's this ideea,if i sad something insulting, i am sory)