Other > General Game Discussion

The New Californian Republic annexes border states

<< < (24/24)

Surf:

--- Quote from: Nice_Boat on October 07, 2011, 03:46:17 AM ---That actually makes it worse ::) You really don't see a problem with helping one gang against the others? And yeah, "nothing" is much better than breaking something that was working perfectly fine. The moral of this riveting tale is not "GMs shouldn't partake in actual Fallout lore" (whatever that is, I don't recall NCR securing any other towns as early as 2238), it's "GMs should take a while and think about consequences of their actions before they start pissing people off".

--- End quote ---

I am looking forward to your groundbreaking, awards winning (as you can never hesistate to mention it!), nobel prize RPG. I am sure it will breach prosa as we know it, poems will have to be newly defined etc  just by your awesome skills. No wonder 2238 goes down the shitter! We just need multiple instances of Nice_Boat !  ::)

Jotisz:
As I said personally I liked the idea the lamest excuse to deny it was the time frame however as I said

--- Quote ---Well we are at 2259 now since a min equal an ig hour, so it wasn't that out of the context...
--- End quote ---
The current time is even more forward therefore we long have passed the end of Fallout 2 I think anything can be made now since it wouldn't mess with the time line anymore not as if 2259 would have messed anything.
I'm a bit sad it ended in just a reset of towns but well not all can end good. Anyway I hope there will be something similar with better welcoming and with a good non linear story arch where player actions would determine the outcome.

Sishare:
The problem was not the idee, it was just how this project had make, on a town who have multiple conflict between lot of faction, and initiate by one of this faction. The major probleme that was not totatly ncr taking town, just 4 ncr guard for one team....

Nice_Boat:

--- Quote from: Surf on October 18, 2011, 09:20:27 AM ---I am looking forward to your groundbreaking, awards winning (as you can never hesistate to mention it!), nobel prize RPG. I am sure it will breach prosa as we know it, poems will have to be newly defined etc  just by your awesome skills. No wonder 2238 goes down the shitter! We just need multiple instances of Nice_Boat !  ::)

--- End quote ---
Nice strawman argument there. The problem is I didn't say anything about my skills being better than yours or even your skills being bad, I just said that you dropped the ball big time which could've been easily avoided if in the heat of the moment you paused for a minute to think about the consequences of supporting one player faction against the others/breaking a TC-enabled town, not to mention the poor execution of this idea so many people here have already mentioned. Another problem is that instead of learning from your mistakes you get verbally aggressive on anyone daring to criticize you, but since from what I've heard you're no longer a GM after this latest stunt that's just this one problem solved ::)

Jotisz:

--- Quote from: Sishare on October 19, 2011, 12:09:53 PM ---The problem was not the idee, it was just how this project had make, on a town who have multiple conflict between lot of faction, and initiate by one of this faction. The major probleme that was not totatly ncr taking town, just 4 ncr guard for one team....

--- End quote ---
I know Redding was always a central place with all the big factions trying to take control of it. However as I said previously all the other towns wouldn't have made sense if they were taken by NCR. The problem that TC action broke in Redding wasn't such a big problem after all there are plenty of other cities around and as far as I understand it wasn't meant to be forever well it didn't last much time also, but the ending of it it was... can't say anything of it I expected something else can't grasp what but something more...
Personally what I see wasn't the loss of a TC town but not used up opportunity that could have given some color to the game (the recent news about TC and factions will sure give some nice touch to the game after wipe btw).

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[*] Previous page