Other > Suggestions
Keepin the crap out of the Suggestions Forum
avv:
--- Quote from: Ulrek on January 25, 2011, 06:06:46 PM ---Adding a poll like this means you'll either have to make forum accounts to vote, and to bump your thread so you can at least get your suggestion heared.
So i am against this. people have the right to suggest what they want and not get it auto-junked if no one votes for it in a days time.
--- End quote ---
Have to make more accounts? If a suggy gets downvoted or doesn't even receive votes it means others aren't interested in it.
Besides, what comes to +votes, even if some suggestion had +100 votes it only means devs will pay some more attention to it. If it's boosted with multiaccounts it's still the same suggestion and doesn't get any better no matter how many +1votes it has. It just gets more attention, that's it.
Suggestions would get auto junked only if it receives enough -1 votes compared to plus votes.
Michaelh139:
This also means that things suggested that might be unpopular with the player base but might actually balance/fix/or simply make the game better will get downvoted and ignored as well.
Andr3aZ:
who decides what is a good suggestion anyway?
At the end, we do not choose what gets implemented, so the community still can discuss about it but the final choice lays in devs' hands.
And yes, your point that this community is dumb enough to downvote something that would balance gameplay over their overpowered strategies might be true, but even then: these suggestions will not simply vanish, they are still there and i dont think with such voting systems everyone will only concentrate on top10 uservoted suggestions, especially devs/mods and gms who forward good (good in terms of quality, not votes) suggestions.
Sarakin:
I like it. Also it wouldnt hurt, if new users on this forum couldnt vote (for a while/till they get some posts), so there wont be any trollaccounts or hasty/inexperienced decisions. Or enable regular forum contributers to vote for more +/- points.
Maybe it doesnt belong here, but it could be also affected by reputation of each user (of course, reputation should be added first)
NastyKhan:
I vote yes. Totally. Truly. Fully.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version